Freshwater
Muskellunge
Where to find them, how to catch them and the tackle to use.
01Introduction
The muskellunge is the largest member of the pike family: a long, silvery predator with dark bars, spots or blotches, a duck-bill snout and heavy teeth. Muskies are never abundant, since a lake with one adult per acre is considered a good fishery, and they're famous for following lures without striking. But learn where they live and how to finish every cast, and they're far more catchable than their "fish of 10,000 casts" reputation suggests. Fifty inches is the benchmark for a trophy.
02Where to Catch
Range: native to the St. Lawrence-Great Lakes and Mississippi basins, from Quebec to southeastern Manitoba, south in the Appalachians to Georgia and west to Iowa. Many states outside that range stock pure muskies, tiger muskies or both.
Habitat: muskies favor lakes and rivers with submerged weedbeds, rock and wood near deeper water, though some live in clear lakes with few weeds. The best big-fish spots are usually "complexes" that combine several kinds of cover: a thick weedbed, rock points, a reef or two and a steep rock wall, all close to deep open water. Thick weeds that most anglers skip often hold the biggest fish.
Seasonally:
- Spring: shallow, sheltered bays and coves that warm first, often 1 to 3 feet deep; west-facing bays catch afternoon sun and wind and warm fastest.
- Summer: weed beds and weed edges; in the hottest weather, bigger fish drop to deeper points, ledges and drop-offs.
- Fall: weed beds until the water cools into the 40s°F, then open water near points and drop-offs where baitfish school.
03How to Catch
Casting and the figure-eight
Casting big lures around cover is the classic approach. Muskies often follow a lure to the boat, so finish every retrieve with a figure-eight: stand at the side of the boat, push the rod tip into the water and swing the lure in wide loops the length of your rod. Practice it on every cast so it's automatic when a fish appears. With a follower, speed up rather than slowing down; if the fish is level with or above the lure, it's usually ready to eat. Changing depth, pulling the lure out of sight and bringing it back past the fish, can trigger a hesitant one.
Timing
Muskies can be caught all year, even through the ice. Fishing is fairly consistent from late spring to mid-fall, and early fall is often the best. Low light, overcast days and a warm rain can turn fish on.
Trolling
Trolling covers water and puts big lures in front of fish that are hard to reach by casting: bucktail spinners run just over the tops of submerged weeds, or crankbaits along deep points and drop-offs in late summer and fall. Speed trolling can be productive.
Tiger muskies
Tigers act much like muskies but bite more readily and are often caught by bass anglers. They're at their best when the water warms in early summer and stay aggressive through the heat. Use smaller lures than you would for pure muskies: spinnerbaits, crankbaits and lipless rattlebaits along weed edges and weedy bars.
04Tackle
Use a long (8½- to 9-foot) medium-heavy to heavy rod, which makes the figure-eight easier, with a sturdy reel and braided line, and always use a wire leader. Carry bucktail spinners, crankbaits, jerkbaits, glide baits, big spinnerbaits, large soft plastics and topwaters. Bring a large net, long pliers and hook cutters, keep the fish in the water as much as possible and release it quickly. Check your state's regulations for size and bag limits.
05Questions anglers ask
What is a tiger muskie?
A cross between a muskellunge and a northern pike, with narrow, irregular dark bars that merge on the back. It's sterile, is stocked by fisheries agencies to add a controllable predator, and tends to bite more readily than a pure muskie, often on smaller, bass-sized lures.
Is a muskie really the fish of 10,000 casts?
Not necessarily. Experienced anglers and agencies say fishing the right spots and conditions matters more than hours: complex structure near deep water, low light, overcast skies or warm rains, and well-practiced figure-eights at the boat.
Why do muskies follow my lure without biting?
Following is normal. In-Fisherman's guides say to keep the lure moving into a wide figure-eight beside the boat and usually to speed up; a following fish that's level with or above the lure is often ready to strike.